CHEF PRIMERA
ENES

Breads & Baking · American

Chicken Pot Pie

17 ingredients · 95 minutes · 6 servings

Cook Now
454kcal20.2g protein28.7g fat29.2g carbs~$1.15/ serving*Estimates computed from the ingredient list; cost uses average US supermarket prices. Not a substitute for packaging measurements or your receipt.
No porkNo alcohol · without one

Contains: gluten, dairy, egg

Ingredients

Servings:
1 ¼ cupflour (all-purpose)
8 tbspbutter (cold, cubed, for the crust)
3 tbspwater (ice-cold)
1 ¼ tspsalt
1 lbchicken, thigh (boneless, in 1-inch pieces)
1 ½ cupchicken stock
1 unitbay leaf
3 tbspbutter (for the sauce)
3 tbspflour (for the roux)
¾ cuponion (diced)
½ cupcarrot (diced small)
cupcelery (diced small)
½ cuppeas, green (frozen)
½ cupmilk (whole)
1 tspthyme (leaves)
½ tspblack pepper (ground)
1 unitegg (beaten, for wash)
½ cuppotato (diced small, parboiled)optional
1 cupmushrooms (sliced)optional
2 tbspdry white wineoptional
¼ cupheavy creamoptional
2 tbspparsley (chopped)optional

Method

  1. mix6 min
    cold, by hand
    flour + 0.75 tsp salt + cold cubed butter, pressed into flat flakes rather than crumbs, then + ice water just until it holds when squeezed — visible sheets of butter are what steam the pastry into layers, so stop while the dough still looks underhydrated
  2. rest30 min
    refrigerated, wrapped
    dough — the flour finishes absorbing the water and the gluten slackens, so the round rolls out without springing back or tearing
  3. poach12 min
    bare simmer, lid ajar
    chicken stock + bay leaf + chicken, until the pieces are just firm, then lift out the meat and keep the liquid — a real simmer would tighten the thigh meat and squeeze it dry before it ever reaches the oven, and the stock is now the sauce
  4. sweat8 min
    medium, no browning
    3 tbsp butter + onion + carrot + celery + a pinch of salt, covered, until the onion is translucent and the carrot bends — root vegetables will not soften further once the sauce thickens around them, so this is the only chance to cook them through
  5. mix3 min
    medium, constant stirring
    + flour, cooked until it smells like toast but stays blond, which cooks off the raw-paste flavor while keeping the starch's full thickening power
  6. simmer7 min
    medium-low, whisking
    + poaching liquid a ladle at a time, then + milk + thyme + black pepper + remaining salt, until it coats a spoon and holds a line — a loose sauce will boil up through the vents and a stiff one turns to glue in the oven, so aim slightly thicker than gravy
  7. fold2 min
    off heat
    + poached chicken + frozen peas, then spread into a shallow 8-inch dish and let it cool to warm — filling straight off the stove melts the butter out of the raw pastry on contact and the crust bakes flat and greasy instead of layered
  8. top5 min
    filling + rolled dough draped over and pressed to the rim, egg-washed; the seal at the edge is what holds the lid up as the filling boils underneath
  9. score1 min
    crust, three cuts through to the filling — steam has to leave somewhere or it lifts the pastry off the sauce and leaves a raw underside
  10. bake40 min
    400°F / 205°C, tray beneath
    pie, until the crust is deep brown and the sauce bubbles visibly at the vents; pale crust means the interior starch is still slack
  11. rest10 min
    out of the oven
    pie — the sauce is thinner than it looks at 200°F and will run off the spoon; ten minutes lets the roux set so a cut portion stands up