Sweet & Morning · American
Pumpkin Pie
Cook Now346kcal7.8g protein17.1g fat40.6g carbs~$0.69/ serving*Estimates computed from the ingredient list; cost uses average US supermarket prices. Not a substitute for packaging measurements or your receipt.
VegetarianPescatarianNo porkNo alcohol · check
Contains: gluten, dairy, egg
Ingredients
Servings:
| 1 ¼ cup | flour |
| ½ cup | butter (cold, cubed) |
| 3 tbsp | water (ice-cold) |
| 1 tsp | salt (divided) |
| 1 ¾ cup | pumpkin purée (one 15-oz can) |
| ¾ cup | brown sugar |
| 1 ½ tsp | cinnamon (ground) |
| 1 tsp | ginger (ground) |
| ½ tsp | nutmeg (grated) |
| ¼ tsp | cloves (ground) |
| 3 unit | eggs |
| 1 ½ cup | evaporated milk (one 12-oz can) |
| 1 tsp | vanilla extract |
| 1 cup | heavy cream (whipped, for serving)optional |
Method
- mix5 minpie dough, minimal handlingflour + 1/2 tsp salt + cold butter rubbed to pea-flakes, ice water just until it holds — the same short-crust contract as every pie in the catalog: visible butter now is flake later
- rest30 minrefrigerated, then rolled and crimpedthe dough before rolling into the pan with a tall crimped edge — tall on purpose: this is a full-to-the-brim custard and a lazy rim is an overflow
- bake15 min375°F, blind, weightedthe shell lined and weighted until set and barely colored — the custard bakes at a temperature too low to ever cook raw dough beneath it; the blind bake is not optional unless soggy is the family tradition
- simmer5 minthe purée and spices, stirred in a saucepanpumpkin + brown sugar + cinnamon + ginger + nutmeg + cloves + remaining salt over medium heat until it darkens slightly and smells like pie instead of like a can — this five minutes is the consensus upgrade: it blooms the spices in the squash's moisture and cooks off the tinny raw note that haunts skipped-step pies
- whisk3 minoff heat, eggs lastthe warm (not hot) pumpkin base + evaporated milk + vanilla, then the eggs — in that order, because eggs whisked into a hot mixture are breakfast; the custard should pour like heavy cream
- bake50 min350°F, until the center barely wobblesfilling into the warm shell, baked until the outer ring is set and a two-inch center circle still shimmies — the crack down the middle of family pumpkin pies is the signature of overbaking, not of Thanksgiving; carryover heat finishes the center on the counter
- rest120 minfully cool, then refrigeratedat least two hours — pumpkin custard cuts cleanly only when fully set and cool, and the pie is genuinely better the next day, which is the entire logistical miracle of Thanksgiving: the pie is DONE on Wednesday