Sides & Vegetables · American
Sweet Potato Casserole
Cook Now345kcal5.3g protein13.2g fat52.4g carbs~$0.88/ serving*Estimates computed from the ingredient list; cost uses average US supermarket prices. Not a substitute for packaging measurements or your receipt.
Vegetarian · without onePescatarian · without oneNo porkNo alcohol · check
Contains: gluten, dairy, egg, tree nut
Ingredients
Servings:
| 3 lb | sweet potatoes (whole) |
| ½ cup | butter (divided) |
| ⅓ cup | milk (warm) |
| 2 unit | eggs |
| 1 tsp | vanilla extract |
| ¾ tsp | salt |
| ½ tsp | cinnamon (ground) |
| ½ cup | brown sugar (for the topping) |
| ⅓ cup | flour (for the topping) |
| 1 cup | pecans (chopped) |
| 2 cup | marshmallows (mini — the other congregation)optional |
Method
- roast55 min400°F, whole, until collapsingsweet potatoes whole in their skins until a squeeze meets no resistance — roasting drives moisture out and concentrates the sugars where boiling washes both away; the deep caramel note of a good casserole starts here or never
- mash6 minflesh scooped hot, half the butter in firstthe flesh + half the butter melting on contact, then warm milk + eggs + vanilla + salt + cinnamon whipped smooth — the eggs are the difference between a casserole that slices and a puddle of mash wearing a topping; taste before adding ANY sugar to the base, because roasted sweet potatoes usually need none
- mix3 minthe streusel, rubbed to clumpsbrown sugar + flour + pecans + the remaining butter (cold, cubed) rubbed with fingers until it clumps like wet sand — the flour is what keeps the topping crumbly instead of melting into candy glass
- bake30 min350°F, streusel over the filled dishuntil the topping browns and the center puffs slightly — the eggs are setting a light soufflé under the crunch; marshmallow partisans add theirs for the final 10 minutes only, until bronzed, because marshmallows in from the start are a black lacquer by minute twenty
- rest10 minbefore serving — like every custard-set dish it firms as it cools, and it reheats gracefully, which is why it is the one Thanksgiving side worth making a day ahead