Sweet & Morning · Latin American & Caribbean
Pay de Queso
Cook NowVegetarianPescatarianNo porkNo alcohol · check
Contains: gluten, dairy, egg
Ingredients
Servings:
| 6 oz | Maria cookies (finely crushed) |
| 6 tbsp | butter (melted) |
| 8 oz | cream cheese (room temperature) |
| 14 oz | sweetened condensed milk |
| 12 oz | evaporated milk |
| 3 unit | eggs |
| 2 tsp | vanilla |
| 1 tsp | lemon zestoptional |
Method
- mix5 mincookie crumbs evenly moistened with melted butterMix until the crumbs hold together when squeezed, then press an even layer across the base and slightly up the sides of an 8- to 9-inch pie dish. Uneven thick spots stay greasy while thin spots crumble.
- bake8 min350°F until crust smells toasted but has not darkenedPrebake the crust briefly to set the butter-bound crumbs. This creates a barrier against the wet custard and gives clean slices after chilling.
- mix4 minfilling blended smooth at low to medium speedBlend cream cheese smooth first, then add condensed milk, evaporated milk, eggs and vanilla. Stop as soon as uniform; excessive aeration creates bubbles and a spongier texture instead of a creamy custard.
- bake50 min350°F; edges set and center still has a gentle unified wobbleBake until the perimeter is firm but the center moves as one piece when nudged. Waiting until the middle is rigid overcooks the eggs and trades a creamy interior for a grainy one.
- rest45 mincool at room temperature before refrigerationCool gradually so the custard finishes setting without severe contraction. Do not slice warm: the filling is still restructuring and will tear rather than cut cleanly.
- chill120 minrefrigerated until fully coldChill at least two hours before slicing. Cold firms both the cheese custard and the butter in the crumb crust, which is what turns a soft baked filling into a clean pie slice.