Sweet & Morning · American
Key Lime Pie
Cook Now466kcal9.1g protein27.5g fat48.1g carbs~$1.09/ serving*Estimates computed from the ingredient list; cost uses average US supermarket prices. Not a substitute for packaging measurements or your receipt.
VegetarianPescatarianNo porkNo alcohol
Contains: gluten, dairy, egg
Ingredients
Servings:
| 1 ½ cup | graham cracker crumbs |
| 6 tbsp | butter (melted) |
| 3 tbsp | sugar |
| 4 unit | egg yolks |
| 5 unit | lime (zest of 2, juice to 1/2 cup — about 5) |
| 1 ¼ cup | sweetened condensed milk (one 14-oz can) |
| 1 cup | heavy cream (for the topping) |
| 2 tbsp | powdered sugar (for the cream) |
| 1 pinch | salt |
Method
- mix4 mincrumbs + butter + sugar, pressed firminto the pan, up the sides, packed hard with the base of a measuring cup — a loosely pressed graham crust is sand by slicing time; packed, it cuts clean
- bake10 min350°F, the crust aloneuntil fragrant and a shade darker — the pre-bake sets the butter and toasts the crumbs; skipped, the crust drinks filling and goes soggy from below
- whisk4 minyolks + zest first, then milk, then juicein that order, and watch the trick: as the lime juice goes in, the mixture visibly thickens with no heat — the acid is curdling the condensed milk on purpose; this 'sopa' stage is the pie working, and the pinch of salt keeps all that sugar honest
- bake15 min350°F, until set at the edges, wobbly centerthe filling in the warm crust, briefly — the shortest bake in the catalog's pie chapter, just enough to set the yolks; overbaked key lime goes grainy and loses the silk the acid built
- rest210 mincool, then refrigerated at least 3 hoursfully cold — this pie is served cold or not at all, and it slices best on day one after a proper chill; the flavor argument for overnight is real but the crust pays for it
- whisk4 mincream + powdered sugar to soft peaksand spread or pipe over the cold pie — soft peaks, not stiff: the cream is a cool counterweight to the filling's acid, and overwhipped cream reads as frosting on a pie that doesn't want any