Sandwiches & Handhelds · American
Tuna Salad Sandwich
Cook Now565kcal46.4g protein24.4g fat40.2g carbs~$3.50/ serving*Estimates computed from the ingredient list; cost uses average US supermarket prices. Not a substitute for packaging measurements or your receipt.
PescatarianNo porkNo alcohol
Contains: gluten, egg, fish · May contain: soy
Ingredients
Servings:
| 10 oz | tuna, canned (drained hard, flaked) |
| 4 tbsp | mayonnaise |
| ⅓ cup | celery (fine dice) |
| 2 tbsp | red onion (minced) |
| 1 tsp | dijon mustard |
| 1 tsp | lemon (juice) |
| ¼ tsp | salt |
| ¼ tsp | black pepper (freshly ground) |
| 4 slice | bread (sandwich slices, toasted) |
| 2 unit | lettuce (whole leaves) |
| 2 tbsp | dill pickle (chopped)optional |
| 1 tbsp | sweet relishoptional |
| 1 tbsp | dill (chopped)optional |
| 1 tsp | capers (rinsed)optional |
| 1 tbsp | butter (for the toast)optional |
| 2 slice | tomato (sliced)optional |
| ½ tsp | hot sauceoptional |
Method
- prep3 minpress in the lid or a sievetuna, drained until it stops weeping — every teaspoon of can liquid left behind thins the mayonnaise, and thin mayonnaise migrates straight into the crumb, which is the whole mechanism of a soggy sandwich
- mix1 minin the bowl before the fishmayonnaise + dijon + lemon juice + salt + pepper, whisked smooth first — dressing built on top of the tuna needs stirring that breaks the flakes down, dressing built beside it does not
- fold2 mingentle, few strokes+ drained tuna + celery + red onion, turned over just until coated; stop while the flakes are still visible, since the celery's crunch and the tuna's grain are the only texture the sandwich has = tuna salad
- rest5 mincold, uncoveredtuna salad, so the salt draws a little liquid out of the onion and celery and the dressing tightens back up around the flakes; taste again here, because chilled salt reads weaker than room-temperature salt
- toast3 minmedium, until dry and pale goldbread slices — toasting sets a stiff crust that resists the dressing far longer than fresh bread, which collapses within minutes
- top1 minassemble and cut immediatelytoast + lettuce leaf laid flat as a waterproof layer + tuna salad spread to the edges + second lettuce leaf + top slice; the leaf on each face is a barrier, not a garnish, and skipping it is why the bottom slice goes translucent