Sandwiches & Handhelds · American
Reuben
Cook Now896kcal42.3g protein61.7g fat42.4g carbs~$3.58/ serving*Estimates computed from the ingredient list; cost uses average US supermarket prices. Not a substitute for packaging measurements or your receipt.
No porkNo alcohol
Contains: gluten, dairy, egg · May contain: soy
Ingredients
Servings:
| 4 slice | rye bread (seeded, cut thick) |
| 8 oz | corned beef (sliced thin against the grain) |
| 1 cup | sauerkraut (drained and squeezed dry) |
| 4 slice | swiss cheese |
| 4 tbsp | thousand island dressing |
| 2 tbsp | butter (softened) |
| ½ tsp | caraway seedsoptional |
| ¼ tsp | black pepper (cracked)optional |
| 1 unit | dill pickle (spear, to serve)optional |
Method
- prep3 minin a clean towelsauerkraut wrung out hard over the sink until it stops dripping — a jar-wet kraut releases a quarter cup of brine into the crumb, which is the single reason most home Reubens collapse into a grey, sour mush
- saute4 mindry pan, mediumsqueezed sauerkraut + caraway seeds, tossed until the last surface moisture steams off and the smell turns nutty rather than sharp; set aside
- steam3 mincovered, low, splash of watercorned beef slices piled loosely until just heated through — cold beef is the reason the cheese is still rubbery when the bread is already dark, since the interior has to come up to melting temperature from the middle out
- top3 minassembled, not yet in the panrye slice + dressing + swiss + warm corned beef + drained sauerkraut + second swiss slice + dressing + top rye — cheese on both faces glues the filling to the bread so the stack does not slide apart when flipped
- fry8 minmedium-low, buttered outside faces, pressed lightlyassembled sandwiches, 4 minutes per side, buttering the up-face before each flip — medium-low is not caution, it is arithmetic: rye browns fast and swiss melts slow, and anything hotter gives a black crust over cold cheese
- rest2 minon a rack, not a plategriddled sandwiches upright so trapped steam escapes downward instead of soaking the bottom crust, then cut on the diagonal = Reuben